King of the Birds - the African and European versions
I have come across an intriguing mystery recently while working on two families. Cisticolas are not the most culturally endowed genus but one story is remarkable. It concerns the Cloud Cisticola C. textrix. The species occurs in a broad arc through the eastern half of South Africa and is widely known for its hard, rhythmic, percussive ‘clappering’ note - exceptional, in fact, in a bird so small - which is delivered as it performs a remarkably high dancing flight. Sometimes it is so high it cannot even be seen with binoculars, and an old name for the bird was cloud-scraping cisticola.
The best known of the stories about the cloud cisticola is an old, apparently traditional story found widely across southern Africa. In a version recorded in the Transkei region of the eastern Cape in the early part of the twentieth century, the central drama involves a competition organised by all the birds to find a suitable leader from among their number. With the jackal acting as overall judge, each species attempts to fly as high as possible. None can apparently fly higher than the vulture but, just as jackal asks him to return to Earth as victor, all the assembled birds are startled to observe the tiny silhouette of a cloud cisticola emerging from concealment in the vulture’s plumage and briefly flying higher still. This feathered mite then flies down and is duly crowned their king, but some birds accuse him of cheating, at which he instantly vanishes into a small hole. While owl is set to guard the cisticola’s sanctuary, the others go in search of something with which to dig him out, and when they finally return to discover that the cisticola has already escaped, they are as angry with owl as they are with the initial fugitive. Owl too then vanishes down the hole and to this day he is so hated by other birds he is obliged to fly by night. (There is another Zulu version of the same story but with small variations, most notably the cloud cisticola is replaced as central character by a cisticola relative, the neddicky. See http://www.canteach.ca/elementary/africa7.html)The Xhosa story is most remarkable for its virtually identical structure to a European tale of the winter wren and its own election as king of birds. In this version, the same competition is played out, but the birds involved are the wren and the eagle. This is a really ancient European story and even Aristotle (4th century BC) alludes to the conflict between these two birds. The most resonant parallel is the identical inclusion of the owl’s role, by which is explained that bird’s nocturnal lifestyle and enmity with other birds. This coda to the main wren/eagle competition occurs in the version of the story recorded by the Grimm Brothers.
How can one account for the exceptional similiarities? Is the African version, which surfaces in the early twentieth century according to Godfrey, Robert, Bird-Lore of the Eastern Cape Province, Witwaterstrand University Press, Johannesburg, 1941, pages 92-96, a tale first disseminated by Europeans and then adopted as a Xhosa/Zulu story in its own right? Or is it, indeed, completely independent and the similarities a matter of coincidence?
Very often responses to the same or similar birds are identical regardless of place. For example, behaviours that are encouraging of, and demonstrate deep reverence for, swallows are almost universal. In North America, the purple martin was encouraged to nest near the encampments of Native Americans (in hollowed gourds), just as Europeans have encouraged and protected swallows in Europe, and just as the Chinese have held them in high esteem in China. So how do we interpret the parallels between the stories of the wren and cloud cisticola as King of the Birds? And views or information would be welcome.
Remember that by posting a comment you are agreeing to our Terms of Use. Posted in News, Mark Cocker | No Comments »


Here are 